Member of the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association GreeneSpeak Publications,
LLC, P.O. Box 1003, Waynesburg, PA 15370 Serving Greene & Washington Counties, PA
Contact Editor/Publisher Cindy Bailey: firstname.lastname@example.org or 724-344-7980 Like us on Facebook!
Can't get enough Cindy's Wind? See: Cindyswind.blogspot.com ONLINE GREENESPEAK READERS are clamoring for our Special Report on Waynesburg University's property holdings
and financial matters from the AUGUST print edition of GreeneSpeak hits stands. SEE THAT ENTIRE STORY HERE:
Click here for GreeneSpeak's Special Report on Waynesburg University!
[POSTED AUG. 15, 2014] FROM THE AUGUST WET HEN: Why Waynesburg University
is on our radar....After years of quietly buying properties in the borough, Waynesburg University bulldozed its way into the public eye
this summer by up and demolishing the Skyscraper, with nary a word out loud. Outside of whichever Good ol’ Boys it took
to pull this off, most of us were in the dark – thecommissioners,
other public officials, businesses, property owners, the media, and residents.
GreeneSpeak readers clamored
for information on how much property the college owns, if they pay any taxes and how much, how much they contribute to the
borough, the value of their assets, and more. Newspapers have many roles, including finding information that others don’t
have the time or the means to locate. Waynesburg University refuses to speak with us or provide any information, so we have
located answers without their help. See Pages 7-10. (This isn’t over. GreeneSpeak plans to carry this Open Records battle
through to the finish. Stay tuned)…YOU WILL HAVE TO PICK UP A FREE PRINT EDITION OF GREENESPEAK TO SEE WHAT WE'VE DISCOVERED!
[Posted Aug. 15, 2014] Waynesburg University
owns 25% of Waynesburg Borough's properites, most of which are tax exempt. Is it any wonder they walk around with a BIG STICK?
See the details below for information provided by the Greene Co. Assessment Office.
Click here to see Waynesburg University's Borough Properties 2014
THE DARKNESS HATES THE LIGHT. Waynesburg University continues to
refuse any contact with GreeneSpeak and although it's against the law, they apparently aren't going to allow me to review
their documents or respond to me. So I'm tired of waiting. I will therefore be posting their 990s for the LAST DECADE for
your review. I will make my own conclusions based on what's here because they are afraid of me. I will be pulling out the
most pertinent things I see and commenting on the GreeneSpeak Facebook Page. I welcome your own comments here, but especially
on Facebook. Again, I will caution commenters to stay professional and I can't allow personal attacks on me or anyone else.
You can certainly disagree, but don't accuse me of lies or "no evidence" as one WU professor did. There's plenty
of evidence here, pal! Anyway the 2012 Form 990 is here:
Click to see Waynesburg University 2012 Form 990
WAYNESBURG COLLEGE 'COMPLIED WITH
OBLIGATIONS' IN SKYSCRAPER MATTER
By Cindy Bailey GreeneSpeak Editor/Publisher
Waynesburg Borough Council met July 15th before a packed house. Attending were
council president Chuck Berryhill, members Mark Fischer, Dar Fitch, Patrick Haught, Bryan Johnston, Larry Marshall, Eric Rush,
Miles Davin, Mayor Duncan Berryman, and solicitor Linda Chambers, as well as about 40 citizens, with about a dozen watching
the proceedings from the front office.
Most of the citizens attended in regard to the Skyscraper demolition, which is
still in progress.
During Public the 90-minute public comment period, property owner Mary Beth Pastorius read a lengthy
letter describing her concerns about this "terrible loss....Council, you could have prevented it."
She said "pressure
from Waynesburg University" caused them to ignore their own zoning ordinance, which calls for historic preservation and
retaining the character of the town.
Demolition of the building affects the tax base, and economic revitalization because,
"vacant lots don't attract business," she said.
She also expressed concerns about secrecy. "You
did not inform the public....There was no public input," she said, adding that two days prior to demolition, the borough
manager told her he had no knowledge of what was going on. "And I believe him," she said.
A number of potential
investors turned away from the Skyscraper Pastorius said, when they were told, “You can’t have it. The university
Her recommendations included adopting an active demolition ordinance, a master plan, more open communication
via e-mail, and requesting Act 13 funds from the county to create a small grant program for property and business owners in
Berryhill said the demolition ordinance sounded like a good idea.
Robert Linn, who identified himself as a "Pittsburgh attorney" representing Waynesburg University, responded
that the college "complied with its legal obligations,” adding that there was no secrecy or "undue influence"
from the college.
Resident Paul Clutter accused council of "kissing up" to the
college instead of caring for the people of the town.
"We can't stop people from buying property,"
Fischer said the building had been discussed when
then-owner John McNay presented plans for renovation, but, “but Waynesburg University had concerns and I was skeptical….I’m
friends with (college president) Doug Lee. I consider him a good friend. We were in the fire department together….The
university was dubious and said ‘We’re going to step in and buy this.’”
Resident Jeff McCracken said people should not forget that the college fixed up
Fitch said the Skyscraper was dangerous.
Chambers asked Linn if the university would be making the area safe for the Rain
Day Festival. Linn said he would relay the message.
The site has been unsecured and unsupervised since the demolition began June 23. The sidewalk and nearest traffic
lane have been open since the morning of June 24, even during active demolition.
Marshall said nearly 50 blighted properties were recently identified in the area and when the borough
tries to cite them, “people complain.” He said a code enforcement officer a few years ago who was getting things
done was fired by council because of it.
Sally Cameron who owns the Fashion Shop and the theater, said she has concerns about the empty lot where Lam’s
Garden formerly operated. “Parks don’t drive the economy,” she said, adding that the town needs foot traffic.
“Knocking buildings down without a plan” leads to less retail businesses, she said.
Fischer pointed out that the borough has received a state grant for a comprehensive
plan, noting that “there will be a lot of opportunities for input.”
Johnston said the college does a lot of good.
Karen Calvert of the former Our Glass Creations said, “We need more retail, but there are no
buildings.” She asked why there is no sign on the Interstate highway referring to the town’s historic district.
A lengthy discussion ensued with Chambers offering to check on this.
Pastorius told council she was “thrilled” that the lengthy conversation about historic
preservation had taken place. "What happens in the downtown affects everybody," she said.
Waynesburg Borough meets this Monday, July 14th @ 6 p.m.
I hope to see you there. I have prepared a list of issues and questions that GreeneSpeak has, for your consideration. I call
THE TOP 10 THINGS WAYNESBURG COUNCIL
WILL WISH YOU DIDN'T KNOW.
Here are the first
BOROUGH'S DEMOLITION REQUIREMENTS ARE VERY WEAK. Why are the borough demolition requirements so vague? Is this to
make it easier for property owners to avoid historic preservation? Why is there nothing specific in the borough zoning ordinance
about demolition? Why wasn't The college required to submit mitigation plans for demolition impact on properties which
were near the Skyscraper? Why, just one week before the demo began, was the borough manager not informed when it would begin,
nor had he been given the demo permit and accompanying documents to have on file in the borough office? Why hasn't WU been
required to notify the borough or the public of their plans for that property? Will council ever adopt an ordinance regarding
demolition designed to preserve sound buildings whenever possible?
2. SELECTIVE ORDINANCE ENFORCEMENT IS A TRADITION IN WAYNESBURG.
Why was the sidewalk immediately in front of the demolition site kept open throughout the demo? Why was no security
guard on the site at all times during the active demolition? People were picking up bricks one evening after work had stopped,
even as debris was falling all around them. If GreeneSpeak was tearing down a building could we have gotten away with this?
Ask council if they think selective enforcement has anything to do with so many dilapidated buildings in Waynesburg.
THEY ALLOW AND ABET MONOPOLIZATION OF THE TOWN BY THE WEALTHIEST LANDOWNER. Are there any measures to keep one property
owner from monopolizing the town? Is council concerned about this at all? Has the borough considered the ramifications of
the borough's largest landowner (WU) being tax-exempt? Has the borough even considered asking WU to consider using any of
their downtown properties to promote new businesses or provide social services to the local community? Has an agreement been
considered and/or drawn up to assess fees from WU for public safety and public works? They also have the largest population
concentration and one of the largest number of employees in the borough, shouldn't they pay for it directly, instead of "donating"
a FOX FORD police car and a FOX FORD fire truck?
4. BY CODDLING THE COLLEGE, THEY ARE VIOLATING
THE SEPARATION OF CHURCH AND STATE. Ask them, if they are actively and/or tacitly allowing the college to have this
much power and influence in Waynesburg, is council knowingly and intentionally violating the basic constitutional tenet of
the separation of church and state? Are they setting a dangerous precedent here? Would council do the same for a Jewish or
THEY ARE SNUBBING RIGHT TO KNOW AND SUNSHINE LAWS BY KEEPING THE PUBLIC, LOCAL OFFICIALS, AND NEARBY BUSINESS AND PROPERTY
OWNERS IN THE DARK. What if anything will council do to allow more public input on the fate of the town's historic
properties, like holding a public meeting at least several weeks before demolition begins? Why weren't the county commissioners,
as nearby property owners, informed about any of it? Is thus lack of information the reason why nothing was done to mitigate
damage to Hooper Park until the day AFTER demolition began? Why wasn't WU required to inform nearby property and business
owners about possible demolition impact? Why, just days before the demo began, was the borough manager not informed, nor had
he been given the demo permit and accompanying documents to have on file in the borough office.
OF POWER EXISTS AMONG THOSE CHARGED WITH PRESERVING THE HISTORIC CHARACTER OF THE TOWN. TO WIT:
PROSPEROUS & BEAUTIFUL. Is the borough working with Waynesburg Prosperous and Beautiful to search for resources to preserve
the town? With at least 4 members of WP&B board of directors having direct ties to WU, including WU board president Mark
E. Fox, does council have any concerns about an imbalance of power? Main Street manager Larry Marshall who is also borough
council VP, is also on WU's payroll as director of athletics. Not to mention the fact that the WP&B office was long ago
removed from the downtown and relocated up to WU campus.
--BOROUGH COUNCIL. How many council people in addition to Marshall, have direct ties to WU?
Do any council members have concerns about an imbalance of power and influence?
So, just in time for tonight's Waynesburg Council Meeting @ 6 p.m., is my
final installment of the TOP 10 THINGS COUNCIL WISHES YOU DIDN'T KNOW:
7. COUNCIL IS IGNORING THEIR OWN ZONING ORDINANCE.
What sort of measures are being taken to at least TRY to protect the historical character of the downtown as the zoning ordinance
requires ? Why doesn't the borough have their own apparatus in place to organize development of the town in order to
avoid debacles like the Skyscraper demolition?
8.COUNCIL IS REFUSING TO FORM A BOROUGH PLANNING COMMISSION
Why don’t they have their own planning commission that would focus only on the borough, instead of relying on the county
9. COUNCIL IS UNWILLING TO ADOPT THEIR OWN MASTER PLAN. The master plan developed
by the Smith Group for Waynesburg University was developed FOR THE UNIVERSITY but has been controversial in regards to the
downtown (SEE WU Master Plan: http://www.smithgroupjjr.com/projects/campus-master-plan-and-implementation-downtown-vision-plan#)
Has it occurred to council that by having their own planning commission and master plan in place, they could avoid what is
happening right now, which is SELLING OUT TO THE HIGHEST BIDDER AND THEN ALLOWING THAT BIDDER TO TAKE CHARGE OF THE TOWN?
BY CATERING TO ONE LARGE INTEREST (WAYNESBURG UNIVERSITY) COUNCIL IS ABDICATING THEIR SWORN DUTIES. And the question of the
day to ask each individual council member: DO YOU HONESTLY FEEL YOU HAVE CARRIED OUT THE RESPONSIBILITIES YOU WERE SWORN TO
UPHOLD IN REGARD TO PRESERVING AND PROMOTING WAYNESBURG FOR THE EQUAL BENEFIT OF THE LOCAL COMMUNITY, AS WELL AS THE COLLEGE?
FOLLOW THIS CONVERSATION ON THE GREENESPEAK FACEBOOK PAGE!
You can download the Waynesburg University Demolition Permit and associated
documents for the Skycraper here:
Download the Waynesburg University Demo Permit & Documentation
CURRENT TALKING POINT: Do you think
Waynesburg College is taking over the town? And is this OK with you? Get the latest photos and updates on this story .GreeneSpeak
Facebook Page. We're collecting photos and info on the People's Bank. E-mail them to Cindy Bailey: email@example.com.
|Mary Beth Pastorius
[POSTED JUNE 19, 2014 @ 2:40 p.m.]
Saving the People's Bank: Just tell the university
By Cindy Bailey, GreeneSpeak Editor/Publisher
For additional information, see the following documents attached at the end of this story:
Mary Beth Pastorius' Letter to the Commissioners 6-19-14
List of Waynesburg College Trustees
List of Waynesburg Borough Officials
of Waynesburg Prosperous & Beautiful Officials
WAYNESBURG–Mary Beth Pastorius, President of Patorius Historic Properties
of Waynesburg, appealed to the Greene County Commissioners this morning (June 19) for their help in saving the People's Bank.
Now owned by Waynesburg University, the historic but controversial building is apparently set for demolition in the near future.
Pastorius, who recently restored the Ganiear House and is in the process of restoring the Morgan Building, both located
on High St., read a prepared letter (attached at the end of this story). Pastorius and her late husband Tom became well known
in the region for founding the Penn Brewery, which is located in the former Eberhardt and Ober Brewery. They received assistance from
the Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation to restore that building. The Penn Brewery, still a popular attraction, opened
in 1989 and the couple operated
it until 2010. Tom passed away in 2012.
In her letter this morning, Pastorius said she came to the commissioners for
help in halting the demolition because Waynesburg Council does not meet for three weeks, and time is running out. "You
are our last defense to save it," she said.
Present at the meeting were commissioners Chuck Morris and Archie Trader, along
with chief clerk Jeff Marshall, solicitor Cheryl Cowan, and about a dozen audience members.
Commissioner Blair Zimmerman,
who was absent due to family matters, earlier told GreeneSpeak that the county had received a letter that demolition of the
Skyscraper was to begin June 16th. Zimmerman has been a vocal supporter of saving the historic structure, which was recently
declared structurally sound. It has a steel frame and cement flooring throughout. About three weeks ago most of the window glass was removed,
apparently without notifying borough officials.
This morning the commissioners said they have no idea what the status of the
project is now, as they have not been informed.
Noting that "the public has been excluded from the process,"
Pastorius added that the "borough has not informed its citizens about the application for demolition, nor given us a
forum for public comment." Further, she said, council has "abdicated basic responsibility" for preservation
of the Skyscraper, because they have no master plan for the town, nor a planning commission.
"You, the county must step
in and protect your county seat," she said, because the university has had "undue influence for too long on too
many issues" resulting in a "severe lack of balance of power in the borough." She said she is disappointed
that the college won't work "openly and fairly" with the community. "If allowed to continue, this situation
will be the death of the town," she said.
actions she asked the commissioners to consider are: sending a letter to the college president and trustees asking them to
halt demolition; instructing the county planning commission to begin reviewing all major developments in the borough; adding
language to the county comprehensive plan that protects Waynesburg's historic assets; investigating possible conflicts of
interest by council members who are employed by the college; earmarking a portion of Act 13 funds to help downtown property
owners with historic preservation; asking the state Historical and Museum Commission to send the college a letter, reminding
them that the downtown is listed on the Historic Register and therefore historic properties in that district are subject to
certain restrictions. The Skyscraper is considered a "contributing building" in the Historic District, she said.
[See lists of trustees and Waynesburg officials below this story].
Concluding, Pastorius said, "It's time
to draw a line in the sand, and tell the University 'NO.'"
David Farkas of Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation, also spoke in support
of preserving Waynesburg's historic properties, noting, "We've been exploring ways to foster preservation here."
He said there are a number of ways to procure funds for this purpose.
Waynesburg resident Lisa Schwartz, who along with her husband, has
restored two historic homes in town, also voiced her support for preserving the building.
When the public comments were
finished, Morris said, "We are not a player in this....and I don't know if we have any standing," adding that the
commissioners had supported John McNay's recent efforts to renovate the building by signing a lease for the proposed parking
lot. Morris assured Pastorius that the commissioners would discuss the matter.
Trader agreed that the commissioners do
support preservation of properties, noting that the county is trying to obtain the building where Jay Gardner had operated
Waynesburg Floral, but "there are liens on that property," he said.
Morris added that the commissioners had
met with councilman Mark Fischer (the unsuccessful Republican candidate who ran against now-disgraced former state representative
Bill DeWeese) to work out a master plan for the town. The county has offered technical assistance, Morris said, but no work
has been done on the plan to date.
Trader pointed out that money has to be doled out to all parts of the county. "There
is only so much money to go around for these projects," he said.
Pastorius responded, "But Waynesburg is the county seat, a
symbol of what's happening economically in the whole county."
See attachments below for additional information.
[Reader comments are welcome. See below
or you can comment on the GreeneSpeak Facebook Page. If you want to be published, however, you must BE NICE.]
[POSTED JUNE 17, 2014]
LETTER TO THE GREENESPEAK EDITOR
DEMOLITION IS NOT PROGRESS
has applied for a demolition permit to destroy Peoples Bank Building, Waynesburg’s skyscraper. Issuance
of the permit is imminent.
I write to plead with Waynesburg Borough Council and the leadership of Waynesburg
University to stop this madness and begin engaging in open, cooperative town-and-gown relations with the wider business community
to develop a plan for adaptive reuse of Peoples Bank. Tearing down this structurally sound, modern
steel frame building makes no sense, especially when the University has not been required to reveal its plans for the site.
The only hint is in the 2008 Design Plan that they developed, which shows an open festival place on
the lot. Is this the best and highest use of this key piece of land in the middle of the town? Will
it contribute to downtown economic development? Will it add to the tax base?
demolition is the opposite of the green building principles now practiced by so many universities and businesses who understand
that the greenest building is the one already built.
Four years ago, I went
through this building with, among others, architect Kn Kulak and structural engineer Frank Avbel . They
assessed the building to be structurally sound. There’s solid concrete between each
floor of the steel frame and the exterior bricks and mortar are in good condition. The front
façade is the famous Hummelstown brownstone from Dauphin County, PA, the same stone used throughout the brownstone
districts of New York and other East Coast cities.
Inside, there is marble practically everywhere,
including the grand banking room on the first floor, all flights of the staircase (with ornamental iron railing) and restrooms
on each floor. Also remaining are the two Otis Elevators that old timers like me remember. There’s
a handsome decorative tile floor in the entrance foyer. All of this will bite the dust when the wrecking
ball strikes. For what, another vacant lot in the middle of town?
First National and Margaret Bell Miller School were built a few years after Peoples Bank by three different, prestigious New
York City architectural firms. Although I have not yet discovered the architect of Peoples Bank, I’m
sure it was a good one, probably from New York. Furthermore, Peoples Bank is a contributing building
in the Waynesburg District of the National Register of Historic Sites, and as such should be protected.
has implied that the building is unsafe because there were some broken windows on the upper floors. But
a few broken windows or falling bricks do not make a building structurally deficient. The Borough could have easily solved
this problem by requiring the owner to board the windows and maintain the roof.
been claimed that no one is interested in rehabbing this building. That’s simply not true. I
know two reputable developers who were quite interested in this building two years ago but were told by a borough official,
“Hands off. The University wants it.” This is in addition to the
plans proposed last fall by John McNay and Marty Padezanin. Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation
continues to be interested as well.
Quite frankly, Peoples Bank has not been given
a fair chance at adaptive reuse. Because the Borough has no Master Development Plan and no Planning
Commission, citizens have not been informed nor given a chance to express their opinions about downtown developments (such
as this demolition) that will directly impact their pocketbooks and quality of life. Until a Master Plan and Planning Commission
are created, the Borough will continue to be unduly influenced by the University which does have a plan. Sadly,
their plan appears to be to take over the downtown. Then what will they do with it because the tax
base will be gone?
There should be no such thing as a “throw away building,” particularly
not a building of the caliber of Peoples Bank. With an existing dormitory next door, it makes perfect
sense for Waynesburg University to convert this building to housing for seniors or graduate students. Or,
they could enter into a public-private partnership to explore other options for adaptive re-use such as housing or offices
for the growing energy industry. There’s a severe housing shortage in Waynesburg and Greene County
that this building could begin to relieve. Any of these options would be a boost to downtown development
and build the tax base.
It is in the best interest of both the Town of Waynesburg and
Waynesburg University to save this building.
Mary Beth Pastorius, Waynesburg
Stop by and leave your comments on the GREENE
SCREAM page here or on the GREENESPEAK Facebook page!